City of Tampa
Tampa City Council
Thursday, September 21, 2006
The following represents an unedited version of
realtime captioning which should neither be relied
upon for complete accuracy nor used as a verbatim
The original of this transcript was produced in all
capital letters and any variation thereto may be a
result of third party edits and software compatibility
Any person who needs a verbatim transcript of the
proceedings may need to hire a court reporter.
08:42:59 [Sounding gavel]
08:43:04 >>MARY ALVAREZ: The Community Redevelopment Agency is
08:43:06 now called to order.
08:43:07 Roll call, please.
08:43:09 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: Here.
08:43:11 >>GWEN MILLER: Here.
08:43:16 >>ROSE FERLITA: Here.
08:43:16 >>KEVIN WHITE: Here.
08:43:17 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Here.
08:43:18 Mr. Mark Huey is on the agenda.
08:43:20 >>MARK HUEY: Good morning.
08:43:23 A cool morning in a cool city.
08:43:29 This had been scheduled to be quite a significant
08:43:32 meeting in the sense that we were going to bring
08:43:34 forward to you budgets for each redevelopment area to
08:43:37 be approved.
08:43:39 The communities and the staff have been working hard
08:43:42 on those.
08:43:46 In light of millage rate changes and some additional
08:43:49 changes, we are going to defer that final solicitation
08:43:54 for approval probably until the next meeting in
08:43:57 But we will schedule an appropriate follow-up to that.
08:44:02 You do have your budget books.
08:44:04 I appreciate the fact that many of you have had a
08:44:07 chance to meet with, answer questions that you have,
08:44:09 and we appreciate that.
08:44:10 We'll continue to follow up.
08:44:13 In the interim and answer any questions you have about
08:44:15 the proposed budget.
08:44:18 We do have two business items that I would like to
08:44:21 make sure that we take care of.
08:44:23 One is item under number 8, which is reappropriation
08:44:30 for Ybor 1 CRA. The second is item number 10 which is
08:44:35 an assignment of land disposition agreements in the
08:44:39 heights area.
08:44:40 Vince Pardo is here to speak on 8, if you wish.
08:44:49 And David Parkinson is here to speak on 10, if you
08:44:53 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: When I had an opportunity to go
08:44:54 over the budgets last week with Mr. Huey, and Mr.
08:44:59 Chen, I had a question about something in the
08:45:02 Channelside CRA district and then we had a subsequent
08:45:06 And I know there's members of the Channelside council
08:45:10 to discuss.
08:45:10 So maybe we should do 8 and 10 first and then hear
08:45:15 from the public.
08:45:17 >> Okay.
08:45:19 Do we want to call up Vince Pardo for number 8?
08:45:22 >> Yes.
08:45:23 >> Do you want us to remove the items, 1 through 7 and
08:45:33 We have a motion and second to remove items 1 through
08:45:35 7 and 9.
08:45:37 All in favor please indicate by saying Aye.
08:45:42 >> If you will take a similar option later today on
08:45:44 your council he agenda, I believe 32, 38, also.
08:45:51 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Thank you.
08:45:52 Mr. Pardo.
08:45:52 >>VINCE PARDO: Ybor City Development Corporation.
08:45:55 This is a realignment of existing fiscal year 06, TIF
08:46:02 moneys, moving it from one project to another.
08:46:04 We had 172,733 for the Centennial Park project.
08:46:11 The plan was to fund that partially out of this year's
08:46:13 money and partially out of '07.
08:46:16 When the bids came in, of course our highest priority
08:46:19 right now is getting the 15th street stormwater
08:46:21 project complete.
08:46:22 So we have done everything, the board concurred
08:46:27 unanimously, remove 172,733 from the park project into
08:46:31 the stormwater project.
08:46:32 And what I'll be doing next year is looking at funding
08:46:35 the park project out of '07 and '08 moneys.
08:46:40 >> So moved.
08:46:41 >> Second.
08:46:41 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Motion and second to remove number 8.
08:46:46 Motion passes.
08:46:47 Okay, Mr. Parkinson, number 10.
08:46:53 >>> Good morning.
08:46:54 This piece of property was subject of an agreement
08:46:57 that was authorized sometime ago.
08:46:59 One of the terms of that development agreement and all
08:47:02 others that I ever worked on requires formal approval
08:47:05 of the city if they are going to assign their contract
08:47:08 but it does require the original respondent be a
08:47:11 member of that partnership or that corporation.
08:47:13 And they had that request, that resolution authorizing
08:47:18 legal, confirmed that the managing member
08:47:22 certificate --
08:47:28 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: I remember this project.
08:47:29 It was really an attractive proposal for an office
08:47:31 building on Florida.
08:47:34 But -- Tampa, sorry.
08:47:37 But it was prior to the whole Tampa Heights large
08:47:40 scale redevelopment project.
08:47:41 And I just wondered since now we have this major other
08:47:44 player to the north, and from whom we are demanding
08:47:48 much in terms of public amenities, are we allowed at
08:47:52 this point to add anything additional to this in terms
08:47:56 of landscaping, sidewalk, anything that would benefit
08:48:03 the public given that the Tampa Heights area will
08:48:06 suddenly have 10,000 people living half a block away?
08:48:09 >> Not appropriate given the development agreement,
08:48:14 all the way at this point, basically ready to break
08:48:19 down on the property next week.
08:48:22 However, I should say that without regard to the
08:48:24 current heights project, when we were negotiating this
08:48:28 development contract, Bank of America, on a relatively
08:48:33 smaller scale project.
08:48:34 So we did incorporate at its origin.
08:48:49 They are willing to do that at their expense.
08:48:51 >> According to who's design?
08:48:53 >>> The Parks Department design.
08:48:54 It was attached to the development agreement and made
08:48:56 part of the agreement.
08:48:57 So the landscaping then of his project is incorporated
08:49:04 into the edge of the park so that it makes it look
08:49:06 like more of a unit than two half blocks.
08:49:12 In addition, we requested and he agreed to provide the
08:49:15 funding for the maintenance of the park for ten years,
08:49:18 as part of the agreement.
08:49:19 >>MARY ALVAREZ: We need a motion to pass the
08:49:27 >> So moved.
08:49:27 >> Second.
08:49:27 >>MARY ALVAREZ: We have a motion and second to pass
08:49:30 the item 10 resolution.
08:49:32 All in favor indicate by saying Aye.
08:49:36 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: One of the components that we were
08:49:40 looking at this number is number 2, the Channel
08:49:42 District CRA TIF budget, but when I went over that
08:49:51 with Mr. Huey, I was concerned because I heard from
08:49:53 the Channel District council that they were
08:49:55 interested -- I heard this for the last five years --
08:49:57 that they are interested in having a person who is a
08:50:04 proponent of economic developments for the arts in
08:50:06 their area.
08:50:07 So I would like to hear from them on that subject with
08:50:09 the intent.
08:50:10 And when I spoke with Mr. Huey, he had some concerns
08:50:13 about it.
08:50:13 But I think if we hear from the public we can come to
08:50:16 some sort of understanding of what their concerns are,
08:50:18 what they would like to see and how we can include
08:50:21 this in the budget.
08:50:27 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Mr. Huey, are we going to have
08:50:33 Janett --
08:50:35 >>> Yes, we are going to have a brief report.
08:50:38 >>> Jeanie white, president of the Channel District
08:50:40 and I always get to go first.
08:50:43 What we have put together is kind of a plan of what we
08:50:51 want this person to do.
08:50:52 And it would be a consultant, not a city employee.
08:50:56 So it's not a drain on the city fund.
08:51:00 And we have even put together a search committee, if
08:51:06 we need it.
08:51:07 And our thought was that this person would manage all
08:51:15 the different places.
08:51:16 What I plan to do -- I can't make it sound real legal,
08:51:22 Sam, but what I'm trying to do is to make the arts
08:51:27 part of the fabric of the whole district, so that it's
08:51:32 not just one place, it's like we were talking last
08:51:39 night at one of the meetings, on the front of it where
08:51:48 people would see, have children art gallery, you know,
08:51:51 things like that, but will bring the public to see
08:51:55 what art is.
08:51:59 There are many different kinds of art, that not just a
08:52:03 big mural or giant something that stands outside, but
08:52:09 there's something for everybody.
08:52:10 And that's kind of something I have been fighting
08:52:14 forever since I was a little girl.
08:52:17 And so if we have this person, they can go out and
08:52:24 solicit more spaces, for obtainable work space.
08:52:31 I think that there are ways -- and I'm not sure -- and
08:52:34 Sam has to tell us what is legal and what isn't --
08:52:40 that we could actually have a scholarship program for
08:52:48 obtainable grants so that if someone was recommended
08:52:51 by the arts counsel or by John or Mary or somebody,
08:53:00 that is really talented, that we could have a system
08:53:05 of having this person get a reduced rent, which we
08:53:10 could balance with some of the TIF funds, so it
08:53:16 would -- I don't know if that will work or not.
08:53:19 But there are a lot of things to be worked out.
08:53:21 But we need somebody that is not an artist, that is a
08:53:25 business-minded person who likes the arts.
08:53:30 And my thought was -- and we put together the
08:53:37 search -- a committee.
08:53:38 These people have agreed to do it.
08:53:41 Chris, as you know, works with the TIF and I don't,
08:53:47 he's a lawyer that has been very active in the
08:53:50 Henry Lewis, who is our vice-president and lives there
08:53:55 and has lived there for 30 years -- well, has worked
08:53:58 there for 30 years.
08:53:59 Francine McClure who is a new resident and lives down
08:54:07 at the Victory Lofts.
08:54:08 And Ken Stoltenberg, who is our treasurer, and then
08:54:13 ex-officio, Paul Wilburn and I would advise.
08:54:19 And this burn should answer to either this committee,
08:54:24 and this committee would then answer to you.
08:54:27 So it's not, you know, a lot of bureaucracy.
08:54:37 Or if this person could directly come to you.
08:54:43 But you have got to tell me how to make this work.
08:54:46 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Any questions?
08:54:52 >>> Do you understand?
08:54:53 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: I looked at other models, that in
08:54:59 other TIFs where the TIF is recognized something in
08:55:02 the plan like economic development using cultural
08:55:07 tourism as a magnet and hire people to do this
08:55:10 particular thing.
08:55:11 And I think that this is developable within the
08:55:13 language of the TIF.
08:55:15 And in the matrix of bonus densities that Catherine
08:55:18 Coyle is bringing back to us, artist working space,
08:55:23 living space, performance space, interior and exterior
08:55:26 performance space and programming, is part of what
08:55:29 people can get additional bonus densities for.
08:55:32 It's been part of the Channel District since Wilson
08:55:37 stair drafted the first plan 14 years ago and we
08:55:41 worked together on that.
08:55:42 And we have a multitude of things for whom -- that
08:55:47 this individual, this consultant, would have
08:55:49 responsibility of doing.
08:55:50 Right now, when don't have anyone who is doing this
08:55:53 for the Channel District.
08:55:55 Christine generally, the downtown partnership,
08:55:58 promotes arts events downtown.
08:56:01 We have got people promoting things with Ybor TIF
08:56:05 money in Ybor, but the Channel District for which whom
08:56:11 it's the original selling point, doesn't have anyone
08:56:13 to do this.
08:56:14 Now that there are refuse gnaws for the Channel
08:56:16 District it seems this should be part of their budget.
08:56:19 And when I spoke with Mr. Huey about it he said, well,
08:56:22 that's all wrapped into the administrative budget.
08:56:24 And I said, you know, it really is something different
08:56:26 than the administrative budget which funds Mr. Chen
08:56:28 and some of that.
08:56:30 It needs to be for a consultant who specifically works
08:56:33 on cultural tourism, as an economic development tool.
08:56:37 So I would like to see coming back to council when the
08:56:43 budget comes back to the Channel District with this
08:56:46 component in it, and I charge you all in the interim
08:56:50 for working up what you think is a reasonable budget
08:56:52 in terms of the number of hours that its consultant
08:56:54 would need to work on this.
08:56:56 And I think it's not a one-time deal, one-year
08:57:00 specific, and I see this as a reoccurring economic
08:57:03 development function of the Channel District CRA.
08:57:08 >>> And we'd like to start it now so things are
08:57:13 getting organized.
08:57:14 Because right now it's all, you know, we are all
08:57:16 talking about a dream.
08:57:20 We can use the 501(c)3 that I started as part of it.
08:57:24 You know, we can do a lot of things.
08:57:26 But we need some direction from you all of what you
08:57:31 want us to do, how you want us to do it, and from what
08:57:35 I was told the other day, we still have $300,000 left
08:57:41 in the budget for this year.
08:57:43 So we wouldn't even have to wait until October 1.
08:57:49 We could hire a person now, have a letter head, you
08:57:53 know, have a stamp, you know, things like that, that
08:57:58 we don't have now.
08:57:59 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Well, have you come up with a salary
08:58:02 for this person?
08:58:04 >>> I would think that --
08:58:07 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Or budget items for this person?
08:58:10 >>> I would think 60 to $80,000 a year.
08:58:13 You know, they would not get any kind of benefit from
08:58:16 the city so they would have to pay their own, would be
08:58:19 a logical -- because it's a full-Tim job.
08:58:22 It's a job that I've done for 20 years.
08:58:25 >>MARY ALVAREZ: And where would this person be housed?
08:58:29 >>> Well, right now, if they can find a parking place
08:58:31 in amongst -- we'd love to have them in the building.
08:58:36 We have plenty of space.
08:58:37 And it wouldn't cost anything.
08:58:41 We just need paper and a copy machine, and I think we
08:58:45 even got extra CPUs and things like that that can be
08:58:52 >> So what you're looking at is a consultant's fee
08:58:56 plus -- plus office -- for office supplies, and --
08:59:02 >>> Yes.
08:59:06 And tell us what parameters you want to us stay in.
08:59:10 You know, where do you want to us go?
08:59:12 And Ken and Henry have been working on this a lot.
08:59:18 And they know more about the numbers and that kind of
08:59:22 thing more than I do.
08:59:23 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Mr. Huey, do you have any comments for
08:59:28 >>MARK HUEY: No.
08:59:33 In your budget package as Linda suggested, in the
08:59:37 staff administration area, that we included in that
08:59:41 the possibility of arts-related coordination.
08:59:45 I put that in there as a holding because this idea, as
08:59:48 you can tell, is formative.
08:59:51 And I hosted Linda with half of the meeting earlier
08:59:57 this week, did a two-hour work session with all the
09:00:03 It was helpful.
09:00:04 I learned a lot.
09:00:05 And I think we'll continue the dialogue and try to
09:00:07 bring something forward that is fundable.
09:00:09 Again, Sal gave pretty clear direction at the
09:00:12 beginning that the original vision that was described
09:00:15 was not something that was fundable.
09:00:17 So we have to see what is in this idea that truly can
09:00:21 be fundable by TIF resources.
09:00:24 That's our challenge.
09:00:25 We pledge to work, so see what we can come up with as
09:00:29 a recommendation.
09:00:30 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Is there anyone else that wants to
09:00:32 talk about the subject here?
09:00:40 Well, at this point, I don't think that we can give
09:00:43 any direction until we know --
09:00:48 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: What I'd like to do is have another
09:00:51 meeting like maybe next week prayer to the next CRA
09:00:54 meeting and see if I can't get them to do -- we need
09:00:58 to do a better job of clarifying what the
09:01:02 responsibilities were, developing a budget, really
09:01:05 having a package to come before City Council.
09:01:07 >>MARY ALVAREZ: I agree with that.
09:01:10 We just can't arbitrarily say we are going to cut this
09:01:13 out of the budget when we don't know what the budget
09:01:15 is going to look like.
09:01:16 >>LINDA SAUL-SENA: I will work with the staff and the
09:01:19 Channel District council to put this up so it's
09:01:25 something that is clearly stated that can come before
09:01:27 the CRA, with a clear understanding by everyone what
09:01:29 the responsibilities will be.
09:01:32 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Thank you, Channelside district, for
09:01:35 come out, everyone that's from the Channel District.
09:01:42 We hear you, and we'll work with you.
09:01:45 And I'm sure that Ms. Saul-Sena will lead the charge
09:01:48 on this thing.
09:01:49 Thank you for coming this morning.
09:01:51 Janett, you have something to tell us for Drew Park?
09:01:59 >>> Janett La Russa, economic development, a quick
09:02:03 update concerning the strategic action plan process.
09:02:06 We are shooting at having a community meeting and CRA
09:02:10 board workshop in Drew Park the last week of October
09:02:17 with the goal of having the plan brought before the
09:02:19 CRA board for final approval and adoption at your
09:02:22 November 16th meeting.
09:02:24 So that's the general time frame we're working under
09:02:27 And we just wanted to give you an update on that
09:02:32 >> Do you have a date in October?
09:02:34 >>> It will be the last week in October and we are
09:02:36 working on that date, coordinating with your schedule.
09:02:38 >> So we can dress up in Halloween stuff?
09:02:41 >>> If you'd like.
09:02:43 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Anything else?
09:02:46 >>> No.
09:02:47 >> How are things going in Drew Park?
09:02:50 >>> They are getting well.
09:02:51 >> Glad to hear that.
09:02:52 Any other questions from this council?
09:02:56 Mr. Dingfelder?
09:02:57 >>JOHN DINGFELDER: Yes, thank you.
09:02:58 I was looking at the draft budgets for next year.
09:03:01 I wanted to compliment Mr. Huey and your whole team on
09:03:05 the budget.
09:03:12 I want to compliment mark and your team on the budget
09:03:15 I think it's very thorough, it reads well, it's easy
09:03:20 for the eye.
09:03:22 And it's informative, foremost.
09:03:25 The question I had was -- and we'll be discussing that
09:03:29 in length, I guess next week.
09:03:33 Had you hue probably next month.
09:03:34 >>JOHN DINGFELDER: Whenever.
09:03:36 The question I had was, discussion came up about
09:03:42 So I don't know if you want to put it in the same back
09:03:45 or put it in a different document but I think it's
09:03:47 important that council sees what types of carryover we
09:03:51 I guess we have a carryover of items that was approved
09:03:54 today as related to Ybor City, or a modification and a
09:03:58 carryover. Anyway, it's just something I'd like to
09:04:02 >> I appreciate that.
09:04:05 Thank you for the compliments on the budget book.
09:04:07 A lot of work was put into it.
09:04:09 I want to especially acknowledge David Parkinson who
09:04:12 really was a point person in this but all the staff
09:04:16 And again, I hope also reflects the hard work that you
09:04:21 all put in and the accomplishments over the past year
09:04:23 that are reflected in the package in addition to the
09:04:26 >> Unfortunately, there have to be changes on it.
09:04:30 >> We are going to make some changes and get back to
09:04:31 you on that.
09:04:34 It does reflect, also, a commitment on the part of
09:04:37 your staff at the agency to continue to improve and
09:04:43 And I think your observation about reporting to you on
09:04:46 the financial side is another area that Jim Stefan,
09:04:50 who I know was here, we have talked about it, the
09:04:54 important goal for next year, to begin to integrate
09:04:57 into our regular meetings reporting to you, and this
09:05:00 will be an example of an item that we would report to
09:05:05 >>JOHN DINGFELDER: The other thing I wanted to say,
09:05:07 mark, publicly that you and I talked about privately,
09:05:09 is the folks on Harbor Island have expressed an
09:05:13 interest in being included now that the downtown
09:05:15 budgets have some room, a little room to spend some
09:05:20 And so I know you assured me you were going to get in
09:05:24 touch with Harbor Island.
09:05:26 Huh hue yes, this is our first year so it's a new
09:05:29 experience for all of us downtown, and in planning for
09:05:32 this year's TIF.
09:05:34 We are still not sure exactly the amount of TIF that
09:05:37 we'll have.
09:05:38 Next year one of the goals we have for downtown noted
09:05:40 in your budget book is to Croat an advisory board for
09:05:43 downtown, and we'll certainly make sure Harbor Island
09:05:46 is represented on that advisory board.
09:05:48 >>JOHN DINGFELDER: Then the last question I had was
09:05:50 related to the item 8 that I guess you approved
09:05:55 The question I had was, are we just deferring the
09:05:59 Centennial Park improvements to a later date?
09:06:03 I mean, it says that this is -- clearly stormwater is
09:06:08 a more important need than aesthetic improvements to
09:06:11 Centennial Park but obviously there must have been
09:06:14 some noticed for the apartment improvements, otherwise
09:06:17 it would never have made it in the original budget.
09:06:22 >>VINCE PARDO: Unfortunately you came in late,
09:06:25 We expect to come in in the 06-07.
09:06:29 The plan now is fund it out of 07-0.
09:06:32 >>MARY ALVAREZ: Any other questions to come before
09:06:35 this council?
09:06:37 Then we are adjourned.
09:16:16 [Sounding gavel]